In India,
as in England, members of Parliament are central to the functioning of
legislatures. As representatives of the people and the law-making body of the
land, they are expected to act with discipline, decorum and dignity. Recent
sting operations have uncovered corrupt practices involving members of
Parliament which raise questions about Parliamentary functioning. Although
these allegedly erring members have been expelled, several hitherto unexplored
questions have been thrown open.
Though
there have been many instances of expulsion of members, there are only too few
cases in the constitutional history of India when members have been expelled
for the kind of misdemeanour that has allegedly taken place recently. After the
expulsion of Shri H.G. Mudgal in 1951, who was accused of abusing his position
in the Parliament and receiving gratification from the bullion market in
Bombay, there have been a few other expulsions. some of those instances are
discussed below.
Mr.
Subramaniam Swamy, a member of the Rajya Sabha (the House of States) was
expelled in 1976 because he made anti-emergency speeches and referred to the
Indian Parliament as a captive-house. After the imposition of emergency, he had
fled to another country and made these speeches. Post emergency, after the fall
of the Congress government, Mrs. Indira Gandhi was expelled from the House for
breach of privilege and contempt of house by causing intimidation, obstruction,
harassment and institution of false cases.
Expulsion
was always a weapon to satisfy hatred. It was used by political parties against
their rivals. It has to be seen that though there have been expulsions in the
Indian Parliament, the present breach of privilege signifies a grave
misconduct. It was never contemplated that there would be such a time when, on
such a large scale, members of Parliament would be found taking bribe and
expulsion would have to be resorted to.